The Customary Land Podcast
The Customary Land Podcast
The Two Words Nobody Debated: Blue Carbon, Customary Marine Tenure and Fiji’s CUMA Act
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In August 2026, Fiji’s Parliament passed the Commercial Use of Marine Areas Bill, opening a path for customary owners to take proprietary ownership of marine areas used for commercial purposes. The debate was about surf breaks, resorts and tourism. The second half of the definition of “commercial purposes” passed without substantive discussion: emissions reduction projects under Part 10 of the Climate Change Act 2021.
Those two words, emissions reduction, sound like environmental policy. They are a doorway into a property regime: a registrable carbon sequestration property right, tradeable mitigation units, century-long permanence obligations and reversal liability.
In this episode, Spike Boydell takes that question back to his 2009 work with John Sheehan and Jason Prior on what law actually creates when it turns carbon into property. He then asks what happens when Fiji’s carefully developed blue carbon architecture, built on the premise that the foreshore and seabed are State land, meets a newly vested customary marine estate.
The episode covers:
- why a vested marine area may fit none of the Climate Change Act’s landowner categories
- two consent regimes that may operate over the same water
- the difference between a customary tabu and a statutory carbon restraint
- who carries the risk when the carbon is lost
- why the order of questions matters: what continues, what is transformed and by whose authority, and only then what it is worth.
Disclosure: Ulai Baya, co-author of the 2023 Conservation International Fiji blue carbon study discussed in this episode, is Spike’s partner in Customary Land Solutions. Spike also has professional dealings with Siwatibau and Sloan, whose published work is cited.
The Commercial Use of Marine Areas Act 2026 was assented on 22 August 2026 and, at the time of recording, had not yet commenced. The legal questions raised are stated conditionally, and this episode is not legal advice.
Sources:
- Commercial Use of Marine Areas Act 2026 (Act No. 26 of 2026)
- Climate Change Act 2021 (Act No. 43 of 2021), Part 10
- Boydell, Sheehan and Prior (2009), “Carbon Property Rights in Context,” Environmental Practice 11(2): 105–114
- Trenorden and Baya (2023), Blue Carbon in Fiji: Carbon Rights Assessment and Benefits-Sharing, Conservation International Fiji, ISBN 978-982-98166-8-9
- Lawless et al. (2026), “Respecting tenure and the bundle of rights in blue carbon guidance,” Nature Climate Change: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-026-02651-8
- Siwatibau and Sloan, “The Commercial Use of Marine Areas Act – An Update” (September 2026): https://www.sas.com.fj/ocean-law-bulletins/the-commercial-use-of-marine-areas-act-an-update
- High-Quality Blue Carbon Principles and Guidance (2022): https://oceanriskalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/High-Quality-Blue-Carbon-PG_FINAL_11.9.2022.pdf
- Carbon Credits and Other Legislation Amendment (Integrity and Transparency) Bill 2026 (Australia): https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId=r7532
©️ Customary Land Solutions Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
Host: Spike Boydell
Website: TheCustomaryLandPodcast.com
Email: contact@thecustomarylandpodcast.com
Royalty free music used in this episode is from my Artlist.io subscription.
DISCLAIMER: The views, insights and opinions shared on the Customary Land Podcast are those of the Host, any Guests, and others they may cite. They do not constitute legal or financial advice and should not be construed as such by any individual, group or organisation. Before undertaking any dealing or action relating to customary land, individuals, groups or organisations should obtain professional advice from a qualified lawyer, experienced valuer and/or certified accountant with specialist expertise in your particular country. Alternatively, you can contact Customary Land Solutions for advocacy, advisory and capacity building solutions for customary and indigenous landowning groups and trusts on land management, leasehold, valuation and resource compensation issues (E: contact@customarylandsolutions.com).